It has been more than 20 months since the Israeli government began their most recent assault on Gaza and the West Bank. The retaliation for the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack in Israel, has escalated to what the international community has called genocide, therefore, GRIID will be providing weekly links to information and analysis that we think can better inform us of what is happening, along with the role that the US government is playing. All of this information is to provide people with the capacity of what Noam Chomsky refers to as, intellectual self-defense.
Information
Israel Is Inflicting New Horrors on the People of Gaza
‘The Never-Ending Hunger Games of Gaza’: IDF Kills 70+ Palestinians Trying to Get Food Aid
For Families Sheltering in Nylon Tents, Gaza’s Scorching Summer Is Unbearable
Red Card for Genocide: Why FIFA Must Be Held to Account
Children Are Starving in Gaza, as Soldiers Kill People Looking for Food
Israel’s Nuclear Deception: Flagrant Lies and Brazen Hypocrisy
Analysis & History
‘This Is The FINAL SOLUTION To The Gaza Question’: Norman Finkelstein CLASHES With Israeli General
Image used in this post is from https://www.amnesty.org/en/petition/lift-the-blockade-on-gaza-and-stop-the-genocide/
Philanthropy is just reputation laundering for the oligarchy.
It is that time of the year again, when GRIID posts about the various West Michigan Foundations from families that make up the Grand Rapids Power Structure. I start with the DeVos family, which has 5 different foundations.
The Dan and Pamela DeVos Foundation
GRIID has always begun our Foundation Watch work by looking at the foundations associated with the most powerful family in West Michigan, the DeVos family. Two weeks ago I looked at the Dick and Betsy DeVos Foundation, and last week I investigated the Doug and Maria DeVos Foundation. Dan DeVos is currently the CEO of Fox Motors, a co-owner of CWD Real Estate Investments and owns numerous professional sports teams. According to GuideStar, in 2023, the Dan and Pamela DeVos Foundation contributed $13,052,000.00 leaving them with $9,947,343.00 of funds left in their foundation account.
The Dan and Pamela DeVos Foundation made contributions to dozens of entities in 2023, but there are some clear categories of groups they contributed to, such as the Religious Right, Think Tanks, Education-centered groups, and social service entities, to name a few. Below is a listing of each from these categories, with a dollar amount and a brief analysis.
I also include groups that are DeVos owned or created, along with liberal non-profits. With the liberal non-profits, we believe that funding from foundations like the DeVos family foundations ARE a form of hush money. When I say hush money, I mean that these entities will not publicly challenge the system of Capitalism, the wealth gap, structural racism and other systems of oppression, which the DeVos family benefits from and perpetuates through their own political funding.
Religious Right
- Keystone Community Church – $75,000
These religious groups practice varying degrees of conservative politics, which fit into the ideological framework that the DeVos family is committed to.
Far Right Think Tanks and Pro-Capitalism groups
- Mackinac Center for Public Policy – $75,000
Think Tanks influence public policy in individual states, like the Mackinac Center for Public Policy does in Michigan. The Mackinac Center for Public Policy is a right-wing pressure group based in Michigan. Founded in 1987, it is the largest state-level “think tank” in the nation. It was established by right-wing activists to promote “free market,” pro-business policies.
Education-centered groups
- Davenport University – $220,000
- Ferris State University – $50,000
- Grand Rapids Christian Schools – $600,000
- GVSU – $55,000
- Hope College – $25,000
- Northwood University – $4,085,000 (Dan DeVos is on the Board of Trustees)
Half of the Education groups that the Doug and Maria DeVos Foundation contribute to are conservative Christian Schools. GVSU and Northwood University received foundation money, since both of the schools departments and buildings named after the DeVos family, along with the fact that they have influenced business policies at those schools, along with social policies, like delaying GVSU from providing domestic partner benefits by more than a decade because of DeVos funding. In 1994, when faculty and staff at GVSU were meeting with then President Lubbers over the university’s willingness to offer domestic partner benefits, word got out that this was going to happen. At the time GVSU was raising money for a proposed health education building on Michigan St and Peter Cook and Rich DeVos had pledged millions. Once DeVos and Cook found out about the proposal by GVSU to offer domestic partner benefits, they threatened to withdraw their financial support if the university would support a domestic partner benefits policy. GVSU acquiesced to the wish of DeVos and Cook.
DeVos-owned, created or connected groups
- Chicago Cubs Charities – $10,000
- Corewell Health Foundation – $25,000
- Grand Rapids Art Museum – $130,000 (Pamela DeVos is an honorary Trustee)
- Grand Rapids Griffins Youth Foundation – $160,000
- Grand Rapids Symphony Society – $650,000 (Pamela Roland is a Board member)
- John F Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts – $200,000 (Pamela DeVos is a Trustee)
- West Michigan Aviation Academy Foundation – $15,000
- Whitney Museum of American Art – $475,000 (Pamela DeVos is on the Board of Trustees)
Of course all these entities that were created by DeVos family members, also promote their ideological religious and capitalist values. On top of that, it also means that DeVos family members are funding their own entities and using their foundation to fund their own pet projects, and arts and culture institutions that cater primarily to members of the Capitalist Class.
Groups receiving Hush $
- Bethany Christian Services Inc. – $150,000
- Family Outreach Center – $80,000
- Hope Network – $105,000
- Safe Haven Ministries – $10,000
- YMCA of Greater Grand Rapids – $300,000
These groups all provide some sort of social service – people fleeing domestic violence, those who are housing insecure, people with disabilities, adoption and immigration. There are root causes to all of these issues, but these groups are not likely to address root causes and larger systems of oppression. When the DeVos family foundations make contributions, this will increase the likelihood that systems of oppression will not be addressed by these groups.
Foundations rarely make contributions without strings attached. The Dan and Pamela DeVos Foundation has a long history of funding far right and religious right groups, which GRIID began documenting over a decade ago when I started this project. Lastly, it is worth noting that the Dan and Pamela DeVos Foundation, like all of the DeVos family foundations, compliments the campaign contributions they make to further impact public policy and promote their religious and capitalist ideologies.
Three days ago, the GRPD apologist group Voice for the Badge, posted on their Facebook page an article about a Sheriff in Florida who made a statement recently regarding those protesting ICE.
Brevard County Sheriff Wayne Ivey issued a harsh warning Thursday to protesters who use violence in his county: “Throw a brick, a firebomb or point a gun at one of our deputies, we will be notifying your family where to collect your remains at. Because we will kill you graveyard dead. We’re not going to play.”
The Voice for the Badge posted the following comment that accompanied the article from the Orlando Sentinel, stating:
Tells it like it is and will be! Thank You to this amazing Sheriff for protecting his community, citizens and supporting his Deputies!
Voice for the Badge is making it clear that they support cops killing people who engage in more militant forms of protest, and people who do not comply with orders from cops during protests.
In some ways this is similar to what Chief Winstrom said a few days ago at his Press Conference, which was meant to dictate the narrative about what happened between GRPD cops and two Black men who dared to question what the GRPD was doing when they had stopped several Black youth at gunpoint. Winstrom said, Comply now, complain later.
I take what Winstrom means when he says, Comply now, complain later, tack hat his cops will not tolerate people who don’t obey the GRPD, people who are not compliant, and people who push back against policing practices in Grand Rapids.
Voice for the Badge is Johnny Brann Sr.
For anyone who has followed Voice for the Badge, you will know that the public face of the organization is Johnny Brann Sr. Johnny Brann Sr is also the only person who posts on the Facebook page of Voice for the Badge.
Johnny Brann Sr is the owner of Brann’s Steakhouse on West Leonard in Grand Rapids, which also has pro-cop stuff up throughout the restaurant. Johnny Brann Sr has also contributed to political candidates in Grand Rapids in recent years, specifically those that are pro-cop. Here are the names of candidates and how much Johnny Brann Sr and his wife have contributed since the 2020 Election:
- David LaGrand – $1000 in 2024
- Dean Pacific – $2450 in 2024
- John Krajewski – $2450 in 2024
- Andrew Robbins – $2100 in 2022
I have written about the racist and xenophobic nature of Voice for the Badge over the past 5 years, since the group formed after the nationwide George Floyd protests. Tommy Brann Sr. has a very simplistic view of cops, but it is a dangerous view, since he believes that cops are always right and that the public needs to obey them no matter what.
Last night Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE hosted a rally at Calder Plaza to denounce the violence that ICE is committing in Grand Rapids, which includes the monitoring, intimidation, arrest and detention of immigrants.
All four of the West Michigan TV stations and MLive reported on the rally, in varying degrees of accuracy. The Kalamazoo-based channel 3 did a short story, which spent as much time on President Trump’s Executive orders that criminalize immigrants as they did on what the rally organizers were calling for.
The WZZM 13 story was also fairly short, plus they did not provide sufficient context for the rally or the specific demands that Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE were making.
WOODTV8 did a better job of covering the rally, specifically because the centered the voices of immigrants and those most impacted by ICE violence. The 3 minute and 21 second story also provided information about the harm that ICE has engaged in over the past two weeks, but the channel 8 reporter failed to provide details of what the adopting a Sanctuary policy would concretely mean.
The WXMI 17 story was also longer than most local TV news stories, with a running time of 2 minutes and 50 seconds. However, what was problematic about the channel 17 coverage is that they provided more time to Mayor LaGrand and City Manager Mark Washington, using clips from a story back in January, when local organizers first demanded the city adopt Sanctuary policies. The comments from the Mayor and the City Manager were not questioned, nor were those from Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE provided an opportunity to contest the claims of GR City officials
The MLive article came the closest to providing some information on what Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE are calling for regarding the adoption of Sanctuary policies by the City, stating:
“Lowe said the pro-immigration groups are demanding that the city implement six policies. Those policies include prohibiting law enforcement from detaining individuals on civil immigration warrants, and preventing the Grand Rapids Police Department and Kent County Sheriff’s Office from collaborating with ICE officials and not establishing detention centers in the city.”
Originally, there were 5 demands in the Action Alert – an Action Alert that people can still sign – that was presented to the Grand Rapids City Commission in January. Here is the wording of those demands:
In declaring itself a Sanctuary City, Grand Rapids would implement and execute the following:
– policies restricting the ability of state and local police to make arrests for federal immigration violations, or to detain individuals on civil immigration warrants;
– policies restricting the police or other city workers from asking about immigration status;
– policies prohibiting “287(g)” agreements through which ICE deputizes local law enforcement officers to enforce federal immigration law;
– policies that prevent local governments from entering into a contract with the federal government to hold immigrants in detention;
– policies preventing immigration detention centers in Grand Rapids.
Since then, the partner organizations of Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE have included one additional demand, which is for the City of Grand Rapids to not share license plate information with ICE, information that is obtained from the Flock cameras that exist in Grand Rapids.
While there was a great deal of coverage about last nights ICE Out of GR rally and several members of the immigrant community were centered, the local news missed the mark on providing accurate information on what Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE are demanding of the City regarding the adoption of sanctuary policies.
Since last Wednesday, when Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response held a Press Conference to condemn the detention of Carlos Menjivar, there has been no evidence that Michigan Senators Gary Peters and Elissa Slotkin, along with Rep. Hillary Scholten, have shown no evidence that they have even attempted to get a father out of detention.
People have sent over 2,400 online Action Alerts to Peters, Slotkin and Scholten. Since June 12, when the Action Alert was created, Senator’s Peters have said nothing on the websites about the case of Carlos Menjivar, but they have talked about pushing for more investments into Selfridge Air National Guard Base in Michigan, along with making pronouncements in support of Israel’s bombing of Iran.
As for Rep. Scholten, she has not posted anything about the request to get Carlos Menjivar released from ICE detention, which would allow him to re-unite with his family in El Salvador. Rep. Scholten has not posted any Press Releases since June 6, but she has posted a video where she condemns President Trump’s decision to send the National Guard to Los Angeles to suppress the protests that have been led by members of the immigrant community.
Rep. Scholten claims that we need immigration reform, not militarization. However, this is exactly what Scholten was proposing in her awful campaign ads from last fall, her continued criminalization of immigration policy, and her failed Dignity Act, which also calls for increased funding for US Customs and Border enforcement.
The only question is, why do people keep voting for Democrats, when they do not stand up for justice or advocate for immigrants being targeted by ICE?
Last week I reported on the Salvadoran family that went into sanctuary after the father was arrested and detained by ICE after coming to his scheduled appointment at the ISAP office on June 4.
There are several updates I wish to communicate. First, the mother and her three children realized that after the campaign to get Senator’s Peter and Slotkin, along with Rep. Scholten, to call for an immediate release of Carlos Menjivar did not result in any action taken by these politicians, they decided to go back to El Salvador. The family had a voluntary departure option, so the mother took her 3 children and went back to El Salvador on Saturday.
Second, Carlos Menjivar is still locked up in detention and we are still asking for people to sign the Action Alert to apply pressure to Senator Peters, Senator Slotkin and Rep. Scholten to meet the demands listed in the Action Alert.
- For Carlos Menjivar to be released so he can voluntarily depart to his home country of El Salvador.
- Return Carlos’ passport, which the ICE agents took when they detained him.
- Change Carlos Menjivar’s status from deportation to voluntary departure, since a charge of deportation would have lifelong consequences for him.
Third, to attend the ICE Out of GR rally that takes place at 6pm on Tuesday, June 17 at Calder Plaza. People will find out a whole ranges of ways they can resist ICE in Grand Rapids, as well as become involved in the campaigns that Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE have to get the City of Grand Rapids and Kent County to adopt sanctuary policies.
Fourth, to understand that the work of resistance involves a great deal of people and the use of a variety of tactics, skills, time and talent. Here is an incomplete list of all thethings that people have been doing over the past 2 weeks:
- Accompanying people to their appointments at the ICE and ISAP offices.
- Co-ordinating all of the requests for accompaniment.
- Providing legal assistance.
- Creating Press Releases.
- Hosting a Press Conference.
- Offering Sanctuary.
- Hosting a family in Sanctuary.
- Transporting the family in Sanctuary.
- Preparing and delivering food for the family in Sanctuary.
- Driving the family in Sanctuary to Chicago to catch their flight back to El Salvador.
- Conducting media interviews.
- Doing comms work on social media.
- Creating an Action Alert.
- Organizing more GR Rapid Response to ICE trainings.
- Organizations offering space for GR Rapid Response to ICE trainings.
- Documenting ICE activity and GRPD complicity.
- Providing crowd safety for Cosecha organizers.
- Tabling at events to further the work.
- Speaking at rallies to inform the community about the work.
- Having meetings to debrief recent activities, to plan upcoming actions and talk about strategic development of the work.
- Checking in with people doing the work and providing support.
- Affirming the work and other forms of emotional labor.
If you want to be part of this work, the community care work, the resistance work, then come to the rally, attend a future GR Rapid Response to ICE training or contact Movimiento Cosecha or GR Rapid Response to ICE.
The making of a People’s History of the LGBTQ community in Grand Rapids documentary film
(Editor’s note: This article is an excerpt from my book, A People’s History of Grand Rapids.)
In 2011, the LGBT Resource Center at GVSU invited us to create a documentary on the People’s History of the LGBTQ community in Grand Rapids. We interviewed about 75 people, collected archival material and looked at how the Grand Rapids-based commercial news media reported on the LGBTQ community. You can watch that documentary online at this link.
In the process of creating the documentary, there were two things that happened, which provide perfect bookends to this chapter. Months before we were asked to be involved in this project, the GVSU LGBT Resource Center had an arraignment with the local PBS affiliate, WGVU, to run four PSAs that students would create, PSAs that were specific to the LGBTQ movement. Once representatives of GVSU had seen the PSAs, they decided to not air the videos, as they thought that the videos might not sit well with the West Michigan audience.
Frustrated, the LGBT Resource Center at GVSU wanted to figure out how to show the PSAs to a broad audience. The center had also budgeted funds to cover the cost of airing these PSAs, but now that they were denied that opportunity on WGVU, they then approached the Grand Rapids People’s History Project about making a documentary about the history of the LGBTQ community in the area. Thus, the use of censorship led to our work with the LGBT Resource Center and uncovering this powerful part of the Grand Rapids People’s History.
A People’s History of the LGBTQ Community in Grand Rapids film chapters
- Early years
- Organizing the First Pride
- Fighting for Our Rights: The Ordinance Campaign
- AIDS and the Gay Community
- The Religious Right and Homophobia in Grand Rapids
- Sons and Daughters – A Community Sanctuary
- GVSU: Being out on campus
- Political Victories Provide Space: The Emergence of LGBTQ Groups
- Learning from History: Where Do We Go From Here?
At the time of the screening of the film in November of 2011 (we had nearly a thousand people come to the premier of the film that was screened at the downtown GVSU campus), GVSU was in the midst of a major fundraising project to build a new library. The library was going to be named after the mother of Kate Pew Wolters and the university did not want the film to negatively impact their ability to raise the necessary funding for the new library. This is what the university’s lawyer was objecting to, that a family with deep pockets, had one member of their family “negatively depicted” in the Grand Rapids People’s History of the LGBTQ community film. The film did not depict Kate Pew Wolters in a negative light, but it did point out that Wolters was responsible for delivering the message to Dennis Komack, that he would be fired if he continued his involvement with the bookstore known as Sons & Daughters.
This whole incident again reflects the fact that those in positions of power, or those who represent people in power, are threatened by the real history of any community. Those in power have done their best to make sure that movements like the LGBTQ+ Movement does not do anything to threaten their interests. This why it is important that we know this history, as the insurgent group the Zapatistas taught me, Estamos en una guerra en contra del olvido – We are in a war against forgetting. Let us always fight against forgetting and celebrate our collective histories!
It has been 20 months since the Israeli government began their most recent assault on Gaza and the West Bank. The retaliation for the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack in Israel, has escalated to what the international community has called genocide, therefore, GRIID will be providing weekly links to information and analysis that we think can better inform us of what is happening, along with the role that the US government is playing. All of this information is to provide people with the capacity of what Noam Chomsky refers to as, intellectual self-defense.
Information
US and Israel turn “aid” centers into slaughter zones
The Hidden Story: Israeli ‘Aid’ Is Part of Genocide Plan
REVEALED: EU NATIONS CONDEMNING GAZA GENOCIDE SECRETLY INKING BILLION-DOLLAR ARMS DEALS WITH ISRAEL
BIRTHRIGHT IS BOOMING THIS YEAR. HERE’S HOW THE ISRAELI PROPAGANDA TRIP WORKS
Leaked Data From Meta Reveal Israeli Companies Are Struggling To Find Customers
Analysis & History
The Grassroots Movements to Break the Siege on Gaza
Image used in this post is from https://visualizingpalestine.org/visual/anti-palestinian-racism-in-the-media/
The Geo Group: We make profits off of human misery using taxpayer money in Grand Rapids and all around the world
Since June 4th, the public awareness around the existence of the ISAP office in Grand Rapids has increased, since ICE agents arrested and detained immigrants who were coming to their scheduled appointments at 545 Michigan St.
Since then, GR Rapid Response to ICE has been providing accompaniment to people who have appointments at that office, along with those who go to the ICE office at 517 Ottawa NW, just north of the 196 overpass.
A lot more people have also learned about what an ISAP office is. ISAP stands for Intensive Supervision Appearance Program, which is a program operated by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) that provides an alternative to detention for individuals in immigration proceedings.
What is instructive about the ISAP office in Grand Rapids, is that it is run by BI Incorporated, which is a subsidiary of the GEO Group. The GEO Group is one of the largest private prison entities in the world, which also runs prisons that are specifically ICE Detention Centers.
In addition, BI Incorporated also sells location tracking devices, such as ankle bracelets or wrist bracelets that people have to wear, so that ICE or other cops can monitor their whereabouts.
Think about it this way. The people who come to appointments at the ISAP office in Grand Rapids, are in the ICE system. They have to access the BI SmartLINK app, which allows “for real-time communication between officers and clients,” according to the BI Incorporated page. If they have a wrist or ankle bracelet, that is also provided by BI Incorporated. When they come to an appointment at the ISAP office in Grand Rapids, that is owned by BI Incorporated. Lastly, if they are detained by ICE agents while coming to their appointments, which is what happened on June 4, they will be sent to detention, which will soon mean that they will be sent to the GEO Group ICE detention facility in Baldwin, Michigan.
This is what Capitalists call a perfect loop, since every step in the process is owned and operated by the same company, the GEO Group. Not surprising, in 2024, the GEO Group contributed $3,718,518 to political candidates and they spent $1,380,000 lobbying Congress to adopt laws that would make them even more money. To top it off, all of these contract that the GEO Group has, along with their subsidiary BI Incorporated, are government contracts through ICE. This means that taxpayers foot the bill for the hellish systems used to track, monitor, manage, arrest and detain immigrants.
For those wanting to resist what happens at the ISAP office here in Grand Rapids, follow GR Rapid Response to ICE on Facebook and Instagram. For those who want to be involved in a campaign to shut down the GEO Group detention facility in Baldwin, follow the group No Detention Centers Michigan.
Yesterday, Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE held a Press Conference at Fountain Street Church to denounce ICE deception and cruelty against a Salvadoran family.
The family of Carlos Menjivar is claiming Sanctuary out of fear of being detained by ICE, following Carlos’ arrest last Wednesday, June 4, at an ICE raid here in Grand Rapids.
Carlos and his family had been offered a Voluntary Departure by ICE in previous weeks by the ISAP office personnel, so they had already purchased plane tickets to voluntarily fly back to El Salvador this week. Then ICE officials scheduled a check-in appointment at the ISAP office in Grand Rapids, which Carlos attended in good faith, counting on ICE’s verbal agreement with him and knowing he was soon to return to El Salvador. Yet during this appointment, Carlos was taken by alleged ICE agents and is now being held at the Calhoun County Jail in Battle Creek.
Fountain Street Church has offered the family of Carlos Menjivar sanctuary, in the words of Pastor Dannison, “When the residents of our community are under attack or under threat, our doors are open to provide shelter and sanctuary.”
The wife of Carlos Menjivar wanted to go into sanctuary out of fear for her children, but also to publicly denounce how ICE deceived her husband who had already agreed to a voluntary departure.
In response to the cruel and deceptive practices of ICE, Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE have created an online pressure campaign to call upon Michigan Senators Gary Peters and Elissa Slotkin, along with Representative Hillary Scholten to directly intervene on behalf of Carlos Menjivar who was wrongfully detained by ICE last week in Grand Rapids. The online pressure campaign has three demands:
- For Carlos Menjivar to be released before Saturday, so he and his family can voluntarily depart to their home country of El Salvador.
- Return Carlos’ passport, which the ICE agents took when they detained him.
- Change Carlos Menjivar’s status from deportation to voluntary departure, since a charge of deportation would have lifelong consequences for him.
Go to this link to send messages to the three Michigan members of Congress. This pressure campaign will provide an opportunity for Peters, Slotkin and Scholten to leverage their power to assist the family of Carlos Menjivar who was wrongfully detained. Movimiento Cosecha organizer Gema Lowe said, “we are asking for people to sign the pressure campaign and share, because we need as many people as possible to send Peters, Slotkin and Scholten a message that they need to step up and defend families against separation by ICE.
GR Rapid Response to ICE also stated during the Press Conference that Fountain Street Church is modeling the behavior that should be the norm for faith communities in this city. There are roughly 800 churches and this is a chance for Grand Rapids to not only be Beer City, but a City of Sanctuary.
Please sign the online petition and share it widely! .https://actionnetwork.org/letters/free-carlos-menjivar-from-ice-detention/
Grand Rapids Institute for Information Democracy 