Grand Rapids Chamber of Commerce pushes for Michigan to adopt a school voucher program to undermine public education in Michigan
The Grand Rapids Chamber of Commerce recently announced that they are supporting federal initiative that was buried in the One Big Beautiful Bill that would allow a school voucher system to be adopted in Michigan.
The plan has to be adopted before December 31st, and the GR Chamber of Commerce recently sent a letter to Michigan Governor Whitmer. The most relevant sentence in the letter reads:
The Grand Rapids Chamber has consistently supported policies that improve educational outcomes and strengthen connections between K12 education and workforce needs.
None of this should come as a surprise since the GR Chamber off-shoot organization – the West Michigan Policy Forum – endorsed the same plan back in May, which GRIID also wrote about.
In that GRIID article we noted:
“The America First Policy Institute, which was created in 2020 by former Trump administration officials and has ties to the Council for National Policy, a right wing group that has been around since the 1970s and has been supported by the DeVos family for decades. This is what the America First Policy Institute says about the Education Freedom Tax Credit:
The education freedom tax credit (EFTC) allows taxpayers to claim up to $1,700 in dollar-for-dollar federal tax credits for contributions to Scholarship Granting Organizations (SGOs). These SGOs can then fund scholarships to students, which can be used for a range of K-12 educational expenses, including private school tuition and homeschooling.”
Fortunately there is a statewide campaign to oppose this school voucher program, a campaign being organized by the Michigan Education Justice Coalition. There campaign writes:
As we start thinking about winter holidays, Michigan is nearing a decision point. Governor Whitmer has just over 6 weeks to choose whether or not to opt into the federal voucher scam tucked into the One Big “Beautiful” Bill that could devastate millions of kids for years after she leaves office. This voucher scam is another underhanded trick from the Trump administration that puts wealthy interests first, and leaves everyday families and public schools to carry the burden. The time to speak up is short. Michigan voters reject vouchers, so let’s keep telling the Governor to opt-out and keep public dollars in public schools that serve every child.
The Michigan Education Justice Coalition is encouraging people to send a message to Governor Whitmer and incoming Governor Benson to oppose school vouchers for Michigan, which you can sign onto at this link.
The Michigan Education Justice Coalition also points out:
Federal vouchers allow private schools to receive public dollars while maintaining admissions policies that exclude students with disabilities, LGBTQ+ students, multilingual learners, and students of color. Public schools, which serve 90% of all children, would suffer deep cuts as federal tax credits reduce funding available for essential services like Title I, IDEA, and school nutrition programs. Families deserve better than a system that rewards discrimination and undercuts public education.
Just the most recent example of why we should support public education and oppose virtually anything that the Grand Rapids Chamber of Commerce endorses.
I counted at least 27 people who spoke in support of sanctuary policies, exposed the violence of ICE or called for the termination of the Flock contract and an ban on any future ALPR contracts.
You could hear in people’s voices during public comment their frustration and disgust with Grand Rapids City officials who have not only been silent over the past 22 months, or have engaged in gaslighting or deflecting community concerns over the harm being done by ICE, often with GRPD collaboration. Public Comments begins at 18 minutes into the video linked here.
The Public has heard over and over again from commissioners and especially Mayor LaGrand that the city is already fulfilling the 6 demands laid out by Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE. LaGrand and others keep referring to the Office of Oversight and Public Accountability, with information on how they are fulfilling the demands, but this is simply not true. I will list what is on the OPA site and the in bold respond with how the city is not doing what they claim.
The City does not operate a detention facility or jail. Kent County operates the county jail. The Trump Administration has been pushing detention centers in abandoned warehouses and GR has several of those. Cosecha is demanding that the City adopt a policy to never allow vacate buildings/warehouses to be used as detention centers.
The City does not have a 287(g) agreement with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The City currently does not, but the Cosecha demand is to adopt a policy that says Grand Rapids will never sign a 287(g) agreement with ICE.
The City does not enforce immigration detainers. This is true, but Kent County does. When the GRPD arrests immigrants for non-violent offenses they end up in the county jail and then the Sheriff’s Office holds them for ICE.
GRPD is prohibited from conducting investigations or making arrests based solely on a person’s immigration status.
GRPD’s Foreign Nationals Policy prohibits collaboration with ICE on investigations. The GRPD’s Foreign Nationals Policy does provide language that says, “The policy allows officers to provide assistance to federal immigration authorities when there is an emergency that poses an immediate danger to public safety or federal agents.” In addition, Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE have first hand accounts and photo evidence of GRPD assisting ICE during ICE arrests.
Statement from a GR Rapid Response to ICE volunteer
I am including the following statement because it is an example of radical imagination, showing what Grand Rapids Officials could actually do if they really cared about the well being of those being targeted by ICE.
“I have heard and read your previous feedback and remarks. The ones that say protections are in place for our immigrant neighbors, which there are not. Commissioner Belcheck your direct response at the 10.27 meeting about how we might as well call our city a sanctuary was careless, and I was reminded of your dismissing response this weekend, as we gathered as a community and together, worked over the course of an entire day to keep a team of roofers safe from ICE violence while they worked to feed their family.
But I want to speak specifically in response to the previous comments from just about all of you, except Marshall, that there is only so much you can do as a city official and we just don’t understand … I went ahead and put together a quick list of solutions you could and **should** have already done (in combination with passing the privacy safety and dignity for all Ordinance) – a lot of these items you could do in the same 3 minute window I get to stand here and also, are already being done by numerous elected officials in other cities across this country.
– apply public pressure to ICE to get the hell out of our city and off our streets
– perhaps a personal warning to all ICE agents. They are not welcome here. They need to stop Threatening. Stop Masking. Stop Killing and Kidnapping our neighbors.
– Draft an open letter to business owners, building owners, real estate agents and fleet vehicle dealers that participate and cooperate with ICE telling them to stop. Nobody is safe with ICE in our streets.
– declare a ban on ICE activity on city owned and controlled property
– demand that GRPD stop responding and helping ICE when they ask for an escort/help.
Why would you help ICE by deputizing GRPD get away with these inhumane crimes?? It isn’t like GRPD was there to help Mario not be killed. Or, in the very public example from earlier this year – GRPD stood by and helped shove an immigrant’s face into a snowbank while he cried and called out for help.
So much for public servants, they are serving ICE, not our community.
– Stop GRPD from racially profiling at traffic stops and domestic disputes. Immediately give instruction and training to the police departmejt and then heavily enforce that we WILL NOT arrest and detain immigrants for the same exact minor traffic infractions and marital spats that they would let white skinned people walk away from with a warning or smile and wave – because as soon as these buffoons in blue arrest an immigrant, they are put on an ICE hold list. We are complicit as a city in collaboration because our county openly shares personal information with ICE. We have Flock information directly being funneled to agencies tied to ICE. You know how you stop the Grand Rapids Kent County jail to North Lake Detention pipeline David??? You can stop putting immigrants in the damn jail for simple infractions and ticketable offenses.
This is a practice of community care.
This is how we save our neighbors.
Creative, outside the box thinking.
It’s not nothing. Your hands are not tied.”
I urge people to get involved with the work of Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE, especially now as ICE activity in Grand Rapids and Kent County are at an all time high.
Monitoring the Rich and Powerful in Grand Rapids – Segment #13: Proposed Aquarium talk, Condo sales in GR and controlling the narrative from GR A250
One of the 10 principles of journalism is that it must serve as an independent monitor of power.
Now, I don’t claim to be a journalist, more of a media watchdog, but I do engage in movement media. Movement media is reporting and documenting what social movements are doing, which is what I have been trying to do with GRIID since 2009.
However, since I have been monitoring what I call the Grand Rapids Power Structure for nearly two decades, it seems like a good idea to do a Monitoring the Rich and Powerful in Grand Rapids segment.
There are three issues in this segment of Monitoring the Rich and Powerful in Grand Rapids that I want to draw attention to.
The first item I want to look at is a brief conversation between Senior Vice President of Strategic Initiatives with the Grand Rapids Chamber of Commerce Andy Johnson and the Chairman of the Kent County Commission Ben Green. In the just under 1 minute video, they are talking about what an Aquarium for Grand Rapids/Kent County will mean.
First, Johnson says that the GR Aquarium will make the Shed Aquarium in Chicago look like a shed, which means it will be a massive project. Johnson also makes the point about the “economic impact” an aquarium will have, which means more profits for the private sector, while such a project will require millions in public subsidies for such an aquarium. Earlier this year I wrote an article about the Grand Action 2.0 proposed aquarium, which is part of ongoing discussion amongst elected officials, like Ben Greene, but not during public meetings.
The second issue I want to discuss is a recent Crain’s Grand Rapids Business article entitled, Downtown Grand Rapids condo sales spike 54% as new venues drive buyer interest. The Crain’s article states:
“Between Jan. 1 and Nov. 10, 2026, downtown Grand Rapids saw a total of 88 condo sales, up from 58 sales during the same period in 2025, according to multiple listing service data shared with Crain’s. This year’s average list price of $463,551 and average sale price of $448,769 were increases of 9.9% and 9.3%, respectively, from 2025.”
Kate Bylsma, a Realtor at Patriot Realty, also makes the claim that the condo sales increase is due to excitement about what is happening in downtown Grand Rapids. What the realtor doesn’t acknowledge is that downtown Grand Rapids is becoming more and more expensive and less and less tolerant of the poor and unhoused people. In deed, downtown Grand Rapids has become a playground for the rich and professional class.
The third and last thing I want to mention a new documentary co-produced by Ingalls Pictures and GR A250. Ingalls Pictures has already produced short films about the Grand Rapids Amphitheater, the Factory Yards development project in SW Grand Rapids and another short film with GR A250 called July 4th in Grand Rapids.
As we have noted previously, GR A250 was created by members of the Grand Rapids Power Structure to control the narrative around the history of Grand Rapids and the history of the US as a whole. Doug DeVos and Mayor LaGrand spoke at their founding meeting back in 2025.
The new short documentary is called, The Rhythm of Belonging, which was screened at Studio Park earlier this month. You can watch the trailer here below, which also wants to control the narrative about Grand Rapids, with pretty images and messages about what Grand Rapids values. Forty two seconds into the trailer we see GRPD Chief Trigg at the exact moment where the narrator says, “the community leaders who pay attention.”
The trailer is dominated by images of downtown Grand Rapids and towards the end they want to make the connection between being isolated and being connected to people. I’m all in favor of being connected to people and make it a point to do so on a daily basis, but the video does not reflect the lived experience of many Grand Rapidians, which are just struggling to survive. Again, GR A250 wants to control the narrative about this city, which is a narrative that doesn’t question or challenge the status quo or the systems of power and oppression that dominate this city.
International Solidarity in Grand Rapids: Remembering when GR mobilized to protest the US sponsored murder of priests in El Salvador 1989
Thirty seven years ago, on November 16, 1989, Ignacio Ellacuría, S.J., Ignacio Martín-Baró, S.J., Segundo Montes, S.J., Juan Ramón Moreno, S.J., Joaquín López y López, S.J., Amando López, S.J. and their housekeeper Elba Ramos, and her 15 year-old daughter Celina Ramos, were murdered at the University of Central America in San Salvador, El Salvador.
The murder of the six Jesuits, their house keeper and her daughter, was at the hands of the Salvadoran military. There is clear evidence, based on declassified documents that the order to kill the Jesuits came from the highest levels of the Salvadoran military. In fact, some of the Salvadoran soldiers involved in the 1989 massacre, were also graduates of the notorious US Army School of the Americas.
The Jesuits were targeted, in part, because they were seen as the “intellectual authors” of the Salvadoran left. While there is no clear connection between the Jesuits and the armed insurgents of the 1980s (FMLN), the priests were known for their sharp and ongoing critique of the Salvadoran elite. Some of the comments they make that are in this short video are a clear indication of why they were seen as a threat to the Salvadoran power structure.
Grand Rapids Responds
As soon as word got out to the international community about this most recent atrocity in El Salvador, those involved in the Grand Rapids Central American Solidarity movement mobilized.
About 100 people blocked traffic on Michigan Avenue in front of the Federal building in Grand Rapids. The road blockade consisted of people using two long banners that people held up, with one banner stating, “End US Military Aid to El Salvador.” (The US had been giving El Salvador – a country the size of Massachusetts – $1 million a day in military aid throughout the 1980s)
After protestors blocked traffic for 30 minutes, the Grand Rapids police came and threatened to arrest people if they did not move. Most of those blocking the trafficking decided to leave the road rather than get arrested. Shortly afterwards another contingent of people went into Congressman Paul Henry’s office and attempted to make a citizen’s arrest against the Congressman and his staff.
Several people held signs about the most recent massacre in El Salvador, while others read the Congressman’s staff their rights. Another protestor leaned over the counter in the congressional office and picked up the phone to call the GRPD, making the claim that there were “violent crimes being committed at 110 Michigan.”
Eventually, the federal building security showed up and demanded that people leave. One by one the security guards dragged people out and the doors to the federal building were locked so no one could get back in. Congressman Henry consistently supported US military aid to El Salvador, which is why the Grand Rapids Central American Solidarity Movement targeted him.
Another action was organized a week later, where those resisting US policy in El Salvador built coffins and made cardboard tombstones to draw attention to the US financed murders. One protestor began to dig a grave in the federal building lawn, but before they could did a large enough hole to bury the coffin, federal building security came out a took the shovel away. Those protesting US policy were still able to bury half of the coffin and place the cardboard tombstone next to it, while others held signs by Michigan Avenue.
These actions that took place 37 years ago, were in larger part, due to the nearly decade long Central American Solidarity movement that existed in Grand Rapids. For more on the Grand Rapids Central American Solidarity movement, go to the Grand Rapids People’s History Project.
In 1992, there was a ceasefire in El Salvador and a UN Truth Commission was established to investigate the crimes committed in El Salvador between 1980 and 1992. In March of 1993, the UN Truth Commission published their findings, which stated that the Salvadoran military was guilty of 85% of the human rights abuses during that 12-year period and that the FMLN was only responsible for 5%. Congressman Henry never admitted he was wrong or that he was mislead by the Reagan/Bush administrations.
When you understand why people risk coming to the US as undocumented immigrants you begin practice solidarity: An accompaniment story
The dominant narrative about undocumented immigrants in the news media and amongst a large percentage of politicians in the US is that these immigrants are criminals, that they are illegal, and that they should come into the US, “the right way.”
Not only are these sentiments inaccurate, they are ignorant, and they are the result of a long standing history of US immigration policy that is rooted in xenophobia and white supremacy.
However, even more important is the fact that news outlets and politicians do not even bother to ask a basic question, which is to ask why are people willing to risk coming to the US without documentation? This is a simple question, but you would be hard pressed to find the question being asked in centers of power and influence.
What could possibly compel immigrants to enter the US without documentation when there is so much vitriol and so much resentment from so many residents in the US?
Now, I know that there are multiple reasons for people taking the risk of entering the US without documentation and quite often those same people took the risk because of multiple factors. In the 8 week GRIID Class that I recently finished on the History of US Immigration Policy, we spent two weeks discussing the question of why are people willing to risk coming to the US without documentation. The overarching issues are: 1) they are fleeing political violence/persecution; 2) they are fleeing poverty; and 3) they are fleeing the consequences of climate change that has been devastating for their communities, especially in Central America, Mexico and the Caribbean.
However, there are still plenty of of people when presented with this information who either dismiss such claims or they say that these reasons are no excuse for entering the US without documentation.
Yesterday, I had the opportunity to accompany an immigrant that had made that request through GR Rapid Response to ICE. While I can’t share specifics, since I don’t want to put this person at risk of further state repression, here is what I can share about the circumstances for leaving their country and taking the risk of coming to the US without documentation.
The initial reason for leaving their country of origin had to do with the fact that they had family members who were involved in opposition to the current government. Because their family members were involved in challenging the current government they were persecuted, assaulted, terrorized and had property destroyed by government agents. Thus, they fled for their lives.
Once they fled their country in South America, they made their way north, often on foot, where they experienced a litany of violence and trauma that most of us could not even imagine, such as:
- Being sexually assaulted on multiple occasions before crossing the Mexican/US border.
- Enduring long periods of hunger and poor nutrition.
- Spending many days on the trek north dehydrated and weak.
- Being assaulted and robbed of what few possession they had.
- Being subjected to ridicule and harassment from people along the way.
- Being forced to endure extreme heat and extreme cold on a regular basis.
- Force to work shitty jobs that paid little to be able to pay someone to smuggle them in to the US.
- Being sexually assaulted by the person that promised to smuggle them into the US.
Imagine having to deal with this kind of hell because you fled your country of origin, where the government was terrorizing you and threatening your life. Imagine dealing with all of this pain and trauma to then find out that in the US the government here wants to terrorize you as well.
Now, there will still be people saying that these reasons aren’t an excuse to enter the US without documentation or that they still could have come to this country the “right way.” To those people I say – SHUT THE FUCK UP! I mean really? Where is your humanity? Where is your sense of compassion?
Do the ignorant news people, ICE agents, politicians and garden variety of racists simply think that people who take these kinds of risks to enter the US without documentation are skipping thousands of miles and singing along to the Wizard of Oz song, Follow the Yellow Brick Road? Get your head out of your ass, stop believing what those in power tell you and start making connections with real human beings who are here as undocumented immigrants primarily because of US policies that displaced them from their own countries, just like Mario David Coronado Juarez.
Senator Slotkin is missing the election results plot, as is the group she is a member of called Majority Democrats
There has been some recent chatter on social media about what Michigan Senator Elissa Slotkin said at a recent conference in Denver Colorado.
The quote from the online political news site The Hill that has been the primary focus of Slotkin’s comments is:
“If you have elected officials who are spending all their time fighting progressive versus moderate, then they have missed the plot of the election,” she continued. “That new generation is not going to be defined by progressive versus moderate. That new generation, quite simply, is are you on Team Fight or are you on Team Flight?”
Now, these words by Slotkin might seem to be progressive or challenging party norms, but they are essentially meaningless for two main reasons.
First, these comments from Senator Slotkin were delivered at a conference organized by the group Majority Democrats, which hosted a conference of Democrats with the theme What’s Next.
According to their website, Majority Democrats states – “We believe in a life built around four values: possibility, patriotism, personal responsibility, and place.” Based on these values it seem like Senator Slotkin (who is a member of Majority Democrats) has missed the plot about the results of the election.
The outcome of the election was that voters have rejected a form of fascism, economic plundering, and the cruelty of government agencies like ICE. There is nothing about the Majority Democrats commitment to fighting fascism, practicing economic justice and abolishing ICE.
Second, Senator Slotkin, like most elected officials, fails to understand that what you say is meaningless, since it always comes down to your actions and how you vote. In this regard Slotkin should be seen as someone who has not only voted with the Trump Administration, but has engaged in performative actions that are hollow.
When Senator Slotkin made news a year ago by telling US military personnel to disobey orders for deployment I wrote an article pointing out that Slotkin didn’t take her own words to heart while she was in the CIA. Senator Slotkin’s time in the CIA was during the US invasion and occupation of Iraq. The US claimed that Iraq had Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMDs), specifically nuclear capability, as the pretext for the US invasion/occupation in 2003. Those claims were false, but even if they were true, did the US have the right to invade and occupy Iraq? The United Nations didn’t support the US invasion/occupation, so why didn’t Elissa Slotkin refuse orders to be part of that military operation?
ICE has been terrorizing immigrants since they were founded in 2003. As a member of the House and as a US Senator Slotkin has never challenged the very existence of ICE and only recently proposed to offer some mild reforms. Overall, Senator Slotkin’s voting record on immigration and ICE are not reflective of what most immigrants and voters want, which is to abolish ICE.
In addition, you can’t claim to be against US wars and then vote to fund US militarism, like Senator Slotkin did last year when she and Senator Peters both voted for the Trump Administration’s $914 billion US military budget, which also included anti-trans provisions.
Lastly, it is important to note that a significant part of the 2026 election vote was against supporting genocide and candidates/politicians who take money from AIPAC. So it seems that Senator Slotkin doesn’t really understand the plot of the midterm elections.
Is another January 6th action in the works with the Million Crusader Cross March announcement?
We all know how vindictive the Trump Administration can be. The White House has already called into question the validity of the recent mid-term elections and just days after the election there was an announcement made calling for a Million Crusader Cross March at the US Capitol.
The flyer for the event is listed for January 3rd, but the language reads as follows:
- Peaceful Protests & Christian Unity Against the Rigged Midterms
- Bring Your Cross
- Faith, Freedom, Future * For Christ. For Country. Forever.
Of course the flyer is AI generated, as is the image with the Facebook event page Jake Lang Million Crusader Cross March on US Capitol.
Before looking at the list of speakers for the Million Crusader Cross March I wanted to talk about two things. First, GRIID has written numerous pieces about the January 6, 2021 insurrection at the US Capitol. I did an article on the one year anniversary of the January 6th insurrection, how the West Michigan commercial news reported on that event, along with how the ideologically far right groups in West Michigan think about and are connected to the closing days of the first Trump Administration.
Second, I think it is important that we talk about the fact that the event being planned for January 3, 2027 is called the Million Crusader Cross March. The Christian Crusades were a bloody and brutal attack against other religions, particularly against Islam. Therefore, for organizers of the event on January 3, 2027 to call it a Crusade conjures up notions of a holy war against non-Christian religions. However, the reality is that just like the Crusades of the Middle Ages, this Crusade will also be a war dictated by white supremacists.
Of course this kind of talk about another Christian Crusade against Islam is not knew. Erik Prince, the founder of Blackwater, ““views himself as a Christian crusader tasked with eliminating Muslims and the Islamic faith from the globe.” He claims Prince encouraged likeminded employees to “take every available opportunity to murder Iraqis.” This is based on courtroom testimony of former Blackwater employees.
These same sentiments are consistent with the part list of speakers that will be part of the Million Crusader Cross March, along with other vile ideological beliefs that the follow group of Christians espouse.
Jake Lang – Lang is probably the mostly identifiable speaker on the list of those who will address the people who attend the Million Crusader Cross March. On his X page Lang urged 1 million Christian Crusaders to bring their crosses and “STAND LIKE MEN.” Just a few days before this comment Lang called the next insurrection “Round 2,” and claimed, “We are taking this COUNTRY BACK!!!!!!!!!” Land would know, since he took part in the January 6, 2021 insurrection and has boasted about his role that day every chance he can get.
During the current Trump Administration Lang has made a name for himself by not only being an ardent support of Trump, but someone who has consistently called for Muslims and immigrants to to kicked out of the US. Recently, he told the Dearborn, Michigan City Council on August 18: “We will not allow these third world mongrels to run roughshod over us without a fight. … Join the Crusades and extricate this filth from our country. We will have our way! Come blood or sweat. We will have our way! This is a Christian land! Christ is King! Christ is King!”
Pastor David Manning – As pastor of ATLAH World Missionary Church in Harlem, N.Y., Manning long has been known for his opposition to Muslims. In August, he went on the “Pass the Salt” podcast for an episode about “taking back” New York City from Muslims.
Manning directs ATLAH Worldwide Church (All The Land Anointed Holy) in Harlem, New York, and is known for his virulent anti-LGBT views, which he often posts on the church sign, including “Jesus would stone homos.”
Pastor Lorenzo Sewell – Sewell is the pastor of a church in Detroit. He’s been rising in popularity among Republicans since praying at Trump’s second inauguration. According to the online site Right Wing Watch, just days after the Midterms elections Sewell claimed that the elections were stolen and is calling for “another January 6” insurrection at the U.S. Capitol.
When Jake Land appeared in Detroit earlier this year and attempted to burn a copy of the Koran, Pastor Sewell prayed over Lang and told him that he loved him.
Pastor Dale Partridge – As the pastor of King’s Way Reformed Church in Prescott, Ariz., Dale Partridge believes Black people are cursed by God to “a civilizational station of subordination and dependence.” He desires repeal of the 19th amendment because, “Nearly every legalized moral atrocity of the last 100 years was made possible by the female vote.” And he says he won’t allow his daughter to marry a Black man because doing so would lead to lower IQs for their children and because “our Christian forefathers treated interracial marriage as illegal.”
Partridge also said that Germany was “attacked from within by grossly immoral Jewish forces during the Weimar Republic,” which naturally made Nazism “extremely appealing”: “This Nazi movement terrified the Jews because it represented a powerful form of Christian nationalism.”
Evangelist Joel Tenney – Tenney was wearing camouflage in the back of the pickup truck with Lang when they drove onto the sidewalk in Minneapolis while holding a giant cross and a sign that said, “Jake Lang loves Black people, but hates niggers.”
Tenney spoke a few years back during a rally for then candidate Trump, but before the prayer, the pastor said the 2024 presidential election was a “spiritual battle”. “This election is part of a spiritual battle. There are demonic forces at play. But judgment is coming. When Trump becomes the 47th president, there will be retribution against all those who have promoted evil in this country,” Tenney said.
In September Tenney stated that Islam is not compatible with America, then when on to proclaim that Christianity is.
Crusader White Rabbit – White Rabbit and White Rabbit 6 are aliases used by a Crusader named Eric Murgo. Like the others on Lang’s list, White Rabbit is known for anti-Muslim rhetoric. He promoted Lang’s Christian Crusade in Dearborn on social media.
In a video on social media just before Jake Lang came to Dearborn, Michigan Crusader White Rabbit share this video calling on people to come to Dearborn and not allow Islamists to take over America.
Crusader Tori Branum – According to Branum’s website, the Christian war against Islam is crucial because “if we do not awaken now, we may awaken too late — and find that we have allowed love itself to disappear from the face of the earth.”
But lest anyone accuse her of spreading Islamophobia, she says, “There is a very just reason to be afraid” because Muslims are taught “a mind controlling way of life” that starts with “public displays of prayer” and ends with genocide.
Lastly, it is worth noting that Branum, while running as a Republican for District 12 in Georgia, claims she tipped off ICE to a Hyundai plant where South Korean workers were arrested. She has defended the claim and her candidacy despite backlash.
All of the speakers that are listed on the flyer are despicable and hateful people that promote violence against Muslims, immigrants and LGBTQ people.
Over the next month I am going to be monitoring some of the far rights groups in West Michigan, including churches to see of they will be promoting the Million Crusader Cross March on January 3rd.
History of US Immigration Policy: Summary of GRIID Class week #8 – ICE contracts, profiting from pain and family separation
For anyone who could not join the class tonight or who couldn’t find time to be part of this class, I want to share a summary of what was discussed. I also want to provide links and resources for anyone who wants to do their own investigation on the history of US immigration policy.
As with each of the 8 weeks of this class we will rely on the Popular Education resource I created and update regularly. The Popular Education resource provides an important overview of this history, along with a list of books and online resources that can help us with developing a robust analysis of the history of US immigration policy and how to frame it.
In week #1 we relied heavily on the book, No One is Illegal: Fighting Racism and State Violence on the US/Mexican border, which look at the way that Mexicans, Chinese, Japanese, Jewish and even German immigrants have been treated since the mid-1800s.
In week #2 we the responded to the question about why so many immigrants were coming, especially those who were risking their lives to enter the US/Mexican border at unsanctioned border points.
For week #3 I focused heavily on the anti-immigrant narrative or the xenophobic narrative(s) about immigrants that politicians and US news media companies use when talking about undocumented immigrants.
In week #4 we talked about why people are taking the risk of coming to the US without documentation and what the root causes of displacement are. We all read an overview article on the history of US interventions in Central America and discussed the motives of the US government for their support of US corporate interests and regional control of Central America. We then did a more detailed account of the US History with Guatemala.
For week #5 we continued our discussion on the root causes of why people are fleeing Central America and Mexico and taking the risk to come to the US as undocumented immigrants. In week #4 we talked about the history of US foreign policy in that region, along with economic factors, but for week #5 we discussed Climate Change and the so-called War on Drugs as factors of displacement.
First we all read part of Todd Miller’s book, Storming the Wall: Climate Change, Migration and Homeland Security. We also read an interview with Miller about the same topic, but with additional information and analysis.
Second, we read an article from Dawn Paley, an article that beautify summarizes her book, Drug War Capitalism. Paley’s article is entitled, Militarization & Economic Transformation in Colombia & Mexico. In that article she states:
Reconsidering the so-called drug wars requires — in part — evaluating how they have encouraged the expansion of foreign direct investment and extractive industries in Colombia, Mexico and Central America.
Paley discusses how the US used the same model to fight the so-called War on Drugs in Mexico that was used in Colombia.
For week #6 we discussed the ICE detention system in the US. First, we read a chapter from the book Immigration Detention Inc.: The Big Business of Locking up Migrants. This chapter covered the growth of the ICE detention system from the Reagan years through the Biden years, demonstrating how the ICE detention system has always had bipartisan support and how it has continued to grow over the past 45 years.
We also discussed two articles from The Intercepted, one on private detention companies getting bank loans for expansion and one on the use of bounty hunters to track down immigrants for ICE.
In addition, we looked at the data on the GEO Group from OpenSecrets, which shows how much money they contribute to political campaigns and how much they spend on lobbying. Then there was an article on the rapid growth of the detention system that was from August of this year that NPR did. Lastly, we looked at the GEO Group site and their map of detention center locations.
In week #7 we focused on the system of deportation that the US government has used since the late 19th century. The primary text we used was a chapter from Adam Goodman’s book, The Deportation Machine: America’s Long History of Expelling Immigrants.
Two important aspects of the chapter from Goodman’s book were the increase in deportations and the bipartisan nature of deportation as policy.
“Between fiscal years 1986 and 2013, the number of formal deportations (known in bureaucratic parlance as “removals”) rose from around 24,600 to a historic high of around 433,000, while the number of voluntary departures (or “returns”) dropped from more than 1.58 million to just under 179,000. By 2011, formal deportations outnumbered voluntary departures for the first time in seven decades; five years later, they made up three out of every four expulsions from the United States. During this period, formal removals came to resemble voluntary departures in their expedited nature and their restrictions on due processbut they carried much harsher consequences. This shift in how officials deported people represented aradical break from the past century of immigration enforcement policy and practice.”
As for the bipartisan nature of US deportations, the author states:
“In his second term, some migrant activists and advocates took to calling Barack Obama the “Deporterin-Chief.” The moniker stemmed from the fact that formal deportations reached unprecedented levels during his presidency.85 But total expulsions dropped. Assigning responsibility to a particular president or solely focusing on how many people he expelled does not explain immigration enforcement’s punitive turn. It is only by examining the cumulative policy changes under both Republican and Democratic administrations since 1986 -from the unprecedented spending on enforcement, militarization of the border, and increased reliance on expedited formal deportations to the criminalization of migration, externalization of migration control, and expansion of immigration detention-that we can begin to understand the recent transformation of the deportation machine.”
The other resource on deportation we used for week #7 was the site https://mappingdeportations.com/. There are several good videos on this site, along with excellent data and analysis.
Other great resources of information on the https://mappingdeportations.com/ site are the timelines of deportation, maps and the excellent visuals they have created to communicate the realities of who is most impacted by deportation from the US in recent decades.
For our final week of this class, week #8, we discussed how private companies are profiting from ICE contracts, contracts that are ultimately paid for by taxpayers.
First, we discussed an article from the ACLU about the company Palantir and their contract with ICE, in an article entitled All the Ways Palantir is Assisting Trump’s Abusive Removal Campaign. The four ways Palantir assists ICE are:
“ELITE” system for data on targets – Palantir’s Enhanced Leads Identification and Targeting for Enforcement (“ELITE”) system is used in immigration enforcement operations for “identifying and prioritizing high-value targets through advanced analytics.
The Investigative Case Management platform – DHS’s Investigative Case Management (ICM) platform functions as the backbone of the agency’s immigration enforcement apparatus in the United States. As the name suggests, the ICM is for managing cases — supporting ICE through the lifetime of a criminal or civil detention and deportation case.
ImmigrationOS to monitor and track immigrants – According to ICE contract documents, the Immigration Operating System or ImmigrationOS is an augmentation of the ICM, possibly using AI, that seeks to parse vast amounts of data in service of three main priorities of the Trump Administration’s mass deportation agenda.
ICE Tip Processing – The 2025 DHS AI Use Case Inventory also makes mention of a newly deployed “AI-Enhanced ICE Tip Processing” program purchased from Palantir. The software uses generative AI to summarize and categorize incoming tips to ICE, as well as translate non-English tips into English.
Next, we discussed a GRIID article from earlier this year that looks at ICE contracts in Grand Rapids.
Finally, we looked at a three-part short video series from Lawfare Media. The first video is entitled, Deportation, Inc.: The Rise of the Immigration Enforcement Economy. This first video provides an introduction into how ICE came about and the bipartisan funding that has increased over the past two decades.
In the second video the focus is on the immigration detention system.
In the third video the focus is on what is referred to as Removal.
Post Election analysis: Don’t get comfortable, resist state oppression, practice solidarity, take risks and fight like hell for collective liberation
“Voting is easy and marginally useful, but it is a poor substitute for democracy, which requires direct action by concerned citizens against the obstacles to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.” Howard Zinn
A week has not passed since election day and I find myself in a space where I have some fears and concerns.
I remember attending a big rally in 1992 along the lakeshore in Chicago, just months before the Presidential Election. The crowd was estimated to be 100,000 to hear speakers and listen to musicians. There were civil rights activists, LGBTQ activists and anti-war activists, but the person I remember the most was a labor organizer from El Salvador.
The labor organizer from El Salvador talked about the US-backed counterinsurgency war and the challenges his union faced against the Salvadoran death squads. Near the end of his comments he implored people to not forget about what the US was doing in El Salvador and that is Clinton was elected President it would not change the relationship between the US and his country.
When Bill Clinton entered the White House a few months later his administration continued to fund the Salvadoran death squads and the counterinsurgency war the US was waging with the Salvadoran dictatorship.
One of the fears I have in the coming months and years is that all of the euphoria that people are experiencing because of the Democratic Party victories will not translate into substantive change for people, especially the most marginalized. Will the Democrats make it a priority to Abolish ICE, will they end the US war against Iran and stop funding the Israeli genocide in Gaza? Will the Democratic control of Congress result in Medicare for All, for ending Citizens United, and a massive reduction is US military spending? Will the Democratic Party put an end to the war on trans people, call out police killings of Black people, embrace Climate Justice principles, stop providing massive subsidies and tax breaks to corporations, really tax the billionaire class, release the Epstein files and embrace a living wage for all people?
I don’t expect the Democratic Party to do these things, because they don’t really have a history of doing them. My read on history is that whatever meaningful gains we have made have come from social movements – civil rights, LGTBQ, anti-war, tenant unions, climate justice, environmental justice, disability justice, worker movements and immigrant justice movements.
When the FDR Administration implemented worker rights, social security and other policies that benefited working class people, it was not because FDR thought these were good ideas. The Roosevelt administration, coming into office, faced a nation in turmoil. The unemployed were rioting in Detroit, Chicago, Boston, New York and Seattle. In 1934, strikes broke out all over. There was a general strike in Minneapolis, a general strike in San Francisco, hundreds of thousands on strike in the textile mills of the South. Desperate people were taking action on their own, defying the police to put back the furniture of evicted tenants.
Because there was so much resistance happening all around the country, the FDR Administration was essentially forced to adopt New Deal policies or face even more uprisings from the general public. Civil Rights legislation was adopted during the Johnson Administration because there were hundreds of thousands of people protesting in the streets, getting arrested in the lunch counter sit-ins, and Freedom Riders getting beaten by racists for the whole world to see.
I get that people are excited by the election last week, but that was the easy part and now we have to make, indeed, to force politicians to do what we want.
I am concerned about this possibility, because I have witnessed over and over again in my adult life where white liberals have become comfortable when Democrats are in the White House, control Congress or have the majority on the state level.
During the Clinton years NAFTA was put into place, the Crime Bill was adopted, the welfare system was dismantled, the prison industrial complex grew, immigrants were criminalized and the US provide billions to Israel, maintain the economic blockage against Cuba, began the expansion of NATO, sent the US military to Haiti, bombed Sudan and the former Yugoslavia, attacked Somalia, and bombed Iraq regularly, along with imposing economic sanctions on Iraq, which resulted in the deaths of 500,000 Iraqi children.
During the Obama Administration he bailed out Wall Street, did not pass Comprehensive Immigration Reform, deported over 3 million immigrants, allowed the wealth gap to grow, continued US imperialism abroad, supported the coup in Honduras, escalated the war in Afghanistan, maintained $3 billion annually in funding to Israel and overthrew the government of Libya.
During the Biden Administration funding for the police was increased, there was no prosecution of those in the first Trump Administration, a failure to increase the federal minimum wage, did not end student debt, deported roughly 4 million immigrants, increased the US military budget, allowed for an increase of oil drilling in the US, saw the billionaire class grow, saw housing costs and housing insecurity increase, along with unconditionally supporting and funding Israel’s genocide in Gaza.
The worst part of those years is that so many democrats just defended those administrations, often using the weak ass argument that Republicans would be worse.
What was instructive is that during the Clinton Administration there was a resurgence of the labor movement and a radical anti-globalization movement. During the Obama years there was the Occupy Wall Street Movement and the Movement for Black Lives. During the Biden years there was the ongoing immigrant justice movement, the Defund the Police movement, the Rent is Too Damn High movement and a Palestine Solidarity Movement.
Social Movements were born during Democratic Party control, because they did not meet the needs of so many people around so many critical issues. In a recent article from Crimethinc, entitled, The Hot Potato Changes Hands Again: On the 2026 Midterm Elections:
The core issue at the root of the hot potato pattern is that the existing political order cannot address the instability, disparities, and crises of a capitalist system that has concentrated most of the wealth of society in the hands of a few while inflicting grievous social, psychological, and ecological damage on the rest of us. No political party will initiate the kind of revolutionary transformation that will be required to shift to a more egalitarian and sustainable way of life; such change can only come from grassroots mobilization. As long as there is no widespread, powerful social movement that offers the prospect of addressing these problems through profound change, people will continue rejecting one government after another in increasing desperation.
The article continues by stating:
At best, the election results should function as a mandate for grassroots resistance to the Trump administration’s policies, not as a pressure valve for anxiety about them. We must build the grassroots capacity to defend and care for our communities. If we succeed, Democratic politicians will probably try to co-opt whatever we have achieved by offering to do the same things for us through the state. But they will only offer us what we demonstrate the ability to accomplish ourselves, and it is better to develop the ability to address needs directly and consistently than for the well-being of our communities to depend on the outcome of elections.
Don’t get comfortable, don’t blindly defend the Democrats, and don’t think that fascism is gone. Get involved in social movement work, practice Mutual Aid, resist state oppression, practice solidarity, take risks and fight like hell for collective liberation.
At the last Grand Rapids City Commission meeting there was a public hearing regarding the issue of exempting the new downtown Amphitheater from the City’s noise ordinance.
I wrote about who spoke at this hearing, where a majority of people opposed the noise ordinance exemption. I noted that there were three business people – all connected to the DeVos family – who commented about half way through the public hearing. I then went on to write:
These three corporatists and DeVos family operatives who spoke was not lost on those who spoke afterwards, those who were not happy about the invasive noise coming from the Amphitheater. In fact, one person made the point of saying that it was instructive to hear these three speakers who represent business interests and how they were received as opposed to how regular folks, folks who are part of the working class, how they were treated by the City Commission. It was a lovely moment of class consciousness, despite the fact that the City Commission unanimously vote to exempt the Amphitheater from the noise ordinance.
Out of curiosity I checked the agenda packet for the November 10 City Commission meeting, which you can find here, and there continued to be communications send it regarding the unanimous vote on October 27 to exempting the Amphitheater from the City’s ordinance. There were roughly an equal number in support and against the vote, but let me begin with some of the comments from those who opposed exempting the Amphitheater from the City’s noise ordinance.
“During Sept 9, I heard the amphitheater both inside and outside my home. My house
was shaking lol. For me, this meant not okay! I just bought my house and did not sign up for this unexpected obnoxious and totally avoidable distraction.”
“Surely the City knew noise would be an issue, particularly bass noise. This ordinance needs to stand to protect people who have built their lives on the edge of downtown. The spectators IN the amphitheater can surely hear the music just fine. Please reconsider this action.”
“We are fed up with being ignored!”
“That every person who votes yes must be required to sit in someone’s home during the
performances where the sound is penetrating and invading people’s personal space.
They must sit in that home during the entire invasion of noise and feel what it’s like to
have it so pervasive and invasive.”
“On 7/26, I heard the amphitheater inside my home. I could hear very loud base and music. It woke up my husband, myself and my children, who all had sound machines on while we were sleeping.”
“I could hear it over my TV show. If I were having a party that loud the police would come to my home. I could not sleep with my windows open.”
“Also there were other times when we could just feel the vibration of the bass drums with our windows closed. I thought about older people, people working early the next day or families with kids who needed to sleep or get up for school.”
“Make the amphitheater put up sound barriers. The sound traveling all the way over to my home, about 3.5 miles away, is ridiculous and the result of poor sound engineering.”
“Represent your constituents and recognize the fact that you would not be considering making this change to a legitimate ordinance if any one of us, your constituents, were operating outside of any ordinance parameters.”
“On July 17,2026, I heard the amphitheater both inside and outside my home. Base, boom, boom , even with earplugs ,I live 7 miles away there is absolutely no reason for it to be so loud. It actually has health risk. I get up at 4am for work. This noise pollution affects my sleep and performance at work. No to letting we the people vote on this matter. A few greedy people put money before anything or anybody.”
“I have to get up early for work, and I found it difficult to sleep due to the constant bass noise, which can travel for miles. I also have a condition called misophonia, a sound sensitivity associated with neurodivergence that can cause significant overstimulation in response to certain noises.”
“I live just over 2 miles away and I could hear/feel the thumping of the EDM as well as multiple concerts this summer. You disappoint me as mayor.”
I am not going to quote people who supported the City’s unanimous vote to exempt the Amphitheater from the City’s noise ordinance, but I do want to provide the names and profession of the people who support the commission’s vote.
- Bradley Thomas – Progressive Companies which was involved in the development of the Amphitheater and is involved in the soon to be opened soccer stadium.
- Doug Dozeman – attorney and partner for Warner Norcross & Judd.
- Bryan Harrison – Government Affairs Manager for Amway.
- Javier Olvera – Co-owner and President of Olvera Enterprises
- Kara Harrison-Gates – Vice President of Plante Moran (which has contracts with the City)
- Leonard Wernette-Leff – Account Manager for AVI-SPL
- Maddy Miller – Event Coordinator Grand Rapids Chamber of Commerce
- Michael B Verhulst – Founder & CEO of Spesh Construction. Verhulst also site on the Board of Directors for the Grand Rapids-Kent County Convention/Arena Authority, which manages the Amphitheater.
- Monica Steimle-App – Cofounder and CEO of Innovar Advisors.
- Sherry Rennick – CEO of Perspective 3D
- Wendy Ensing – Independent Business Owner at Legacy Finance Solutions, LLC.
- Will Payne – CEO, TRELLIS and Curo Cleaning Services
It is hard not to see how those who are part of business class are all in favor of the City’s unanimous vote to exempt the Amphitheater from the noise ordinance, as compared to what residents, both home owners and renters feel about this matter.
The class division is abundantly clear on this matter as it has been with so many contentious issues facing Grand Rapids in recent years. The City of Grand Rapids has consistently sided with the interests of the Capitalist Class since 2020, like their response to the 2020 Uprising, their refusal to reduce funding to the GRPD, voting to adopt a GR Chamber initiated ordinance to criminalize the unhoused, voting to approve the use of public funds on the DeVos/Van Andel Three Towers project, and voting to approve the use of public funds on the Grand Action proposed projects like the Amphitheater and the soccer Stadium.
Ultimately, the Grand Rapids City Commission ends up rubber stamping whatever provides more funds to those in the Capitalist Class in the city, while ignoring and dismissing working class families, marginalized communities and the unhoused. Another example of West Michigan Nice!














