GR City Commission legislative session focuses on ALPR policies, defers to the GRPD and makes no commitment to reduce state surveillance
During their Tuesday, October 27th Legislative Team Meeting the Grand Rapids City Commission heard from three different presenters on the issue of the Automated License Plate Readers or ALPRs.
Since January of 2025 Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE has been demanding that Flock camera images not be shared with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, but when other groups like DSA became involved, those groups shifted to ending the Flock camera contract and banning any and all ALPR systems in the future.
Back in August there was a major push to have the City of Grand Rapids end their contract with Flock and ban all future ALPR contracts. There were about 60 people who attended the Public Safety Committee meeting on August 25 to pressure that group, but only the Flock Corporation and the GRPD were allowed to formally present. That same night during the City Commission meeting 61 people spoke against Flock cameras in Grand Rapids and most of them also voiced support for the six sanctuary policy demands put forth by Movimiento Cosecha and GR Rapid Response to ICE.
Despite the community’s calls for an end to Flock camera usage, the City decided to fold Flock cameras into their Surveillance Policy, a policy which is weak and essentially acquiesces to the will of the GRPD. Then in September the City/GRPD decided to create a so-called transparency portal. On the GRPD Flock Transparency Portal page under the heading of Community Impact there is a list of ways in which Flock camera use by the GRPD assisted them in solving crimes. In fact, these examples were the same examples that GRPD Deputy Chief Michael Maycroft gave during the August 25th Public Safety Committee meeting. On the right hand of that page there appears a long list of how Flock technology assisted police departments all across Michigan. The whole thing is a joke.
In October, with continued pressure from the community to end the Flock contract and ban all future ALPRs, the City held their legislative session, which mostly focused on ALPRs. You can access the minutes for that meeting from the November 17 at this link.
At the federal level, the City of Grand Rapids has a contract with Potomac Strategic Development Company, LLC to provide updates on legislative matters that may be useful for the city. They are a DC-based firm and deal with a variety of public policy matters. Their representative talked about ALPRs, which are reflected in the minutes:
“During the subsequent ALPR discussion, he also described bipartisan interest in federal proposals concerning restrictions on license plate reader use and funding, while emphasizing that no measure appeared likely to advance imminently and that proposals could potentially be attached to larger legislation.”
At the state level, the City of Grand Rapids has a contract with McAlvey Merchant & Associates, but they were unable to attend and could not provide any updates.
Next, Karyn Ferrick, who is a Government and Legislative Affairs Officer at the City of Grand Rapids, presented information, which are also reflected in the minutes:
Ms. Ferrick reported that seven states Connecticut, Indiana, Kentucky, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon and Washington enacted relevant legislation in 2026. As of September 2026, at least 28 states had statutes expressly addressing ALPR use or data retention. At least 19 states specified retention requirements, while three others required retention standards through local policy. Examples ranged from three minutes in New Hampshire to five years in Alabama; exceptions may apply to active investigations or court-authorized preservation. She also described non-legislative actions in Texas, Missouri and Florida.
Regarding Michigan, Ms. Ferrick reviewed House Bills 5492 and 5493, a bipartisan package referred to the House Judiciary Committee and heard in April, and Senate Bill 1131, introduced in July and referred to the Senate Civil Rights, Judiciary, and Public Safety Committee. The proposals would regulate access to and use of ALPR information and generally require deletion after 14 days, subject to exceptions. She noted that the House package had not advanced out of committee and the Senate proposal had not received a hearing. The memorandum also described ALPR contract decisions and reconsiderations by Michigan communities, including Madison Heights and Lansing.
Members discussed whether the City should advocate on pending state legislation before establishing a clearer local policy position. Several participants emphasized first resolving local questions about ALPR use, including the role of the technology in public safety, the appropriate data retention period, access controls, auditing, and whether information should be shared with outside agencies or maintained in a more restricted system. Members observed that longer retention can support investigations of misuse but can also heighten surveillance concerns.
Other participants emphasized that state legislation could affect Grand Rapids regardless of standards. Participants highlighted community concerns about who can access data, the extent of sharing with other jurisdictions and the importance of public communication. Members also noted differing views about whether ALPR technology should be used at all, rather than only reformed.
The discussion referenced ongoing local surveillance-policy work, review of contracts and the need for Police Department expertise and community input. Staff indicated that the House bill analyses could be distributed and that further comparative research local approach and future legislative priorities.
Outcome: The Legislative Team did not reach consensus or adopt a formal position on House Bills 5492 and 5493 or Senate Bill 1131. Members acknowledged continued local policy work and monitoring of state proposals. No motion establishing a legislative advocacy position was recorded.
As you can see from the minutes the City Commission did not take any action and were only willing to adopt a mild reform position on ALPRs, plus they want to rely heavily on the GRPD and their “expertise.”
It’s always instructive to see how city officials refuse to oppose organized efforts to reduce state surveillance, but either defer to other government departments or the local power structure when they want something done.


Comments are closed.